Scrap the Edmonton Bag Tax

The implementation of bag taxes or fees has become a common practice in many cities around the world as a means to reduce plastic waste and promote environmental sustainability. However, the effectiveness and fairness of these bag taxes have been a topic of debate. In Edmonton, the bag tax has been met with mixed reactions and calls for its elimination.

The Impact on Consumers

One of the main concerns raised by opponents of the Edmonton bag tax is its impact on consumers. The tax adds an additional cost to every purchase, which can be burdensome for low-income individuals and families. While the intention behind the tax is to encourage the use of reusable bags, some argue that it unfairly targets those who cannot afford to make the switch.

Furthermore, the implementation of the bag tax has led to confusion among consumers. Different retailers have different rules and exemptions, making it difficult for shoppers to understand when and where the tax applies. This lack of consistency has resulted in frustration and a negative shopping experience for many.

The Effectiveness of the Bag Tax

Proponents of the bag tax argue that it has been effective in reducing the use of single-use plastic bags and promoting the adoption of reusable alternatives. They point to statistics showing a decrease in plastic bag consumption since the tax was implemented. However, it is important to consider the overall impact on waste reduction and environmental sustainability.

While the bag tax may have led to a decrease in plastic bag usage, it has also resulted in unintended consequences. Some consumers have switched to using thicker, reusable plastic bags instead of single-use ones, which may not be as environmentally friendly as intended. Additionally, the bag tax has not addressed other forms of plastic waste, such as packaging and disposable items.

Alternative Solutions

Instead of relying solely on bag taxes, there are alternative solutions that can be explored to achieve the goal of reducing plastic waste. Education and awareness campaigns can be implemented to encourage consumers to make more sustainable choices. Retailers can also be incentivized to offer discounts or rewards for customers who bring their own bags.

Investing in recycling infrastructure and promoting the use of biodegradable materials are other potential solutions. By focusing on a comprehensive approach to waste reduction, we can address the issue of plastic waste in a more effective and sustainable manner.


The Edmonton bag tax has sparked a debate about its impact on consumers and its overall effectiveness in reducing plastic waste. While the intention behind the tax is commendable, it is important to consider the concerns raised by opponents and explore alternative solutions. By adopting a more comprehensive approach, we can work towards a more sustainable future while ensuring fairness for all consumers.

Scroll to Top